Reviews

Captivating storytelling that is factually based and drama free!

5⭐️ - If you like a podcast formatted like a news story - then Boston Confidential is for you! Barry breaks down the case, focusing on the facts and providing hometown history! Drama free and always on point! I love Boston Confidential ;) 5⭐️

Ms. Gosling
Nov. 19, 2025

Smart, Authentic, and Addictive!

I’ve been a listener of Boston Confidential for a while now and as someone who grew up in Boston, I really appreciate how authentic this podcast feels. The host has a voice and storytelling style that make it an easy and engaging listen. He clearly knows the city, from Roxbury and JP to the North Shore, and understands the history behind each case, both the true crime details and the broader context of Boston itself. I’ve seen a few negative reviews calling him racist or overly pro police, which couldn’t be further from the truth. He gives credit where it’s deserved but isn’t afraid to call out departments when mistakes are made. He’s also covered racism within the Boston Police Department directly, so it’s frustrating to see people misjudge based on a single episode. Overall, this podcast is well researched, thoughtful, and genuinely captures Boston’s true crime stories with depth and respect. Highly recommend.

D.Carley
Nov. 8, 2025

Good!

I’m from Chicago and listen faithfully.

Asil7561
Oct. 29, 2025

Accurate and Concise with a True Boston Delivery!

Boston Confidential is definitely worth a listen! Barry does a great job in sharing the facts and his relatable commentary on true crime stories…I grew up in the Boston area and taking a ride in the “way back machine” allows me to hear stories from a new perspective, with details I often hadn’t heard.

Jules01945
Oct. 24, 2025

It’s Boston through and through

My only gribe is he constantly repeats himself. His thoughts over and over… but then again I honestly think it’s a Boston cultural thing great podcast

President -McKinley
Oct. 19, 2025

Barry is the MAN, YA DIGGG!!?

I love Boston Confidential! Barry is an excellent Host & has the ability to paint such a clear picture with his words, and it makes him great to listen to. 🫡🫡

Jason Markinson
Aug. 4, 2025

LOVE this podcast!

Barry, you are an extraordinary story teller! Your accent makes it even better listening every week. Keep up the great work!

Baes21
Aug. 4, 2025

5 stars for Boston Confidential !

Every episode is told with real talk.

Lorena 2025
July 16, 2025

Barry! Barry! Barry!

Can’t get enough…please do more episodes!

MuseyApproved
June 24, 2025

Barry for prez

I am a lady from GA and I have loved listening to your Karen Reed podcasts. You have fact based discussions and incredibly knowledgeable on the case. Not to mention I am obsessed with your accent!!!

lex1ee123
June 17, 2025

Great job on FACT based coverage.

I truly enjoy this podcast, especially on the Karen Read trial. You just give the FACTS. I do not under the absolute level of CORRUPTION, how an ELECTED Official can go after a person male or female, just to cover up for corrupt police officers, including the State police agency. ALL the Police officers, does NOT matter what office, county these corrupt officers work at/in, there has to be a LARGE number of Officers that know the TRUTH, yet have chosen to LIE. I hope and pray the TRUTH does come out, and every single officer, public officials including Judge/judges are ALL held accountable, and charged, all get serious prison time for covering up a death, then framing an innocent person.

medicshelly223
June 12, 2025

Bahston’s BEST is Barry

Local PI and a great podcaster…the kind of guy you want on your side, and living next door. Love this podcast, wish it posted episodes more frequently and or would consider a deep dive with listener involvement…I have a great idea for a series related to Charlestown.

temptingthemuse
May 28, 2025

Are you doing new podcasts ?

Your’s is my favorite podcast and I have listened to almost all of your podcasts. Your voice is well-modulated ( unlike those who speak loud and intense), so I can relax. I also have read the 2 books that you recommended.. I miss your reporting on the Read trial and others from the way back….

12345sammy
May 13, 2025

Karen Read coverage?

Where has it gone?

LCP 💕
May 12, 2025

Great job on FACT based coverage.

Great job…. I agree with you 100% that public education is down the drain. Keep up the great work…. Thank you for your honest and truthful coverage on the Karen Read case. As a paramedic, that is NOT injuries from a vehicle. Then John”s arm is from a large dog. A 6-ton vehicle will break bones, will leave at a minimum an injury from the bumper/tires, something.

medicshelly223
May 3, 2025

Interested in second trial if Karen Read?

Look absolutely no further. Boston Confidential is the absolute voice you need to hear. Brilliant!

mollygraymollygray
April 22, 2025

THANK YOU!

Best Local true crime podcast in New England! I love that you aren’t afraid to speak your mind.

Bar10kid
April 7, 2025

BARRY MAGUIRE ! LOVE THIS PODCAST AND LOVE YOU!

So glad I stumbled upon your podcast!!!! Listen every day while cooking dinner .. love to hear new episodes! I’m 49 year old mom of 3 teenagers born in Salem, MA , raised in Peabody. My oldest child at Suffolk University-pre law. I love listening to the old cases and how you break them down. I agree with all your points, most recently on the Karen Reed case. It’s beyond fascinating. Nothing more entertaining than real life! Thanks for all your hard work and commitment to this show. I always look forward to listening. Regards , Shannon Woods

shannwoods
March 18, 2025

Great!

Really enjoy your no nonsense style, Barry. Binge listened on an 8 hour drive to Toronto. I look forward to new episodes. Former Methuenite here.

Hooper_67
March 5, 2025

Great Stories

Barry does a good job picking apart crime stories from Boston and New England.

bgags9418
Feb. 25, 2025

Superb

If you want to drink the MA Koolaid of corruption and denial, this podcast isn’t for you. Excellent Research with a dose of humanity , as he dishes out truth….love this podcast!

MAisAjoke
Feb. 24, 2025

Great job on FACT based coverage.

Great job…. I agree with you 100% that public education is down the drain. Keep up he great work…

medicshelly223
Feb. 21, 2025

Barry does great work.

See title 🙂

Obannion76
Feb. 18, 2025

My favorite podcast!!

I love listening to podcasts but especially when they’re from my hometown! Boston Confidential is an excellent well researched podcast. Love the topics and especially the updates on the Karen Read trial. Barry is a great host, well versed in all things Boston and go buy one of his mugs!!!

Pink Purse Mama
Feb. 18, 2025